Should Landlords Consider Housing Asylum Seekers?

A Controversial Proposal – Or a New Opportunity?

The government’s latest proposal to house asylum seekers through private landlords has sparked debate across the rental market. Some see it as a necessary step to address the rising demand for housing. Others view it as another burden being placed on landlords who have already weathered years of pressure and change.

So, why is this proposal causing such division? And could it be a genuine opportunity for landlords in Edinburgh and beyond?

Why Landlords Are Being Asked to Help

The UK is currently facing record levels of asylum applications, and the cost of temporarily housing those awaiting a decision has skyrocketed. In April alone, the UK saw a new record for small boat arrivals. With billions being spent annually on hotel accommodation, the government is now seeking more cost-effective and scalable solutions.

As part of this, it’s turning to private landlords — offering fixed 3- or 5-year rental agreements, with some appealing incentives:

• Guaranteed rent, funded by the government

• All maintenance and repairs covered

• Utilities and council tax paid

• 1, 2, and 3-bedroom properties in demand

The cost to taxpayers would be significantly lower — around £14 per night, compared to £145 per night for hotel accommodation.

Why are landlords being asked to help?

The Potential Benefits for Landlords

At face value, this scheme could offer a welcome change for some landlords:

• Reliable income for several years

• Minimal property management responsibility

• No risk of rent arrears or void periods

For a landlord in Edinburgh, for example, a three-bedroom property under this scheme could achieve a monthly rent of £1,645.

The Concerns Landlords Must Weigh

Despite the potential advantages, the scheme raises several valid concerns:

• Tenant vetting is not possible, meaning landlords have no control over who occupies the property.

• Some have called the scheme “immoral”, arguing it may reduce availability for local families in an already pressurised rental market.

• Mortgage complications: Not all buy-to-let lenders allow properties to be let to third-party providers such as Serco, and those that do may have strict criteria.

• Reputational risk: If a landlord needed to recover possession of the property, lenders may be hesitant to act when vulnerable individuals are involved.

Before moving forward, it’s vital to check with your mortgage provider or speak to a specialist broker before you decide on this route.

Could This Be the Start of a Reset?

The relationship between landlords and government has been rocky in recent years. From the removal of mortgage interest relief to ongoing uncertainty over EPC targets, landlords have often felt like an easy target.

But this new approach — asking landlords to help deliver a national housing solution — may signal a small but significant shift in tone. It demonstrates that, despite past policies, the government still recognises the essential role landlords play in society.

Whether this signals a more collaborative future remains to be seen.

Proceed with Caution — But Keep an Open Mind

Understandably, this proposal has generated mixed reactions. For some, it offers a low-risk, high-certainty income stream. For others, the lack of tenant control and mortgage risks are deal-breakers.

As with any investment decision, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons based on your own financial position and long-term goals.

If you’re a landlord in Edinburgh considering this opportunity, I’d be happy to provide honest, tailored advice. At The Property Experts, we work with a limited number of clients to ensure every property is handled with care and consideration.

A three-bedroom property in Edinburgh could yield £1,645 per month under this scheme — but it’s not suitable for everyone.

📞 Get in touch today to arrange a free consultation and explore whether this is the right fit for your property portfolio.

You can also check market rents and review your portfolio online with us and our Portfolio Review Tool will also help guide you to enable you to maximise your investments:

Portfolio Review Tool